A question worth sitting with
What are holidays — really?
Holy days, harvest festivals, borrowed traditions. Most of what we celebrate has older roots than we realize.
Christmas, Easter, even the way we mark time itself — it's all layered with meaning the church inherited, baptized, and made its own. The history is fascinating once you start pulling threads.
Let's start with the most honest question a child has ever asked in church: what does the Easter Bunny have to do with Jesus? If you grew up sitting in a pew in a new spring dress trying to connect the risen Savior with a cartoon rabbit hiding colored eggs in your grandmother's backyard, you were not missing something. The connection is genuinely thin. And when you finally took Religion 101 in college and found out that Easter borrowed its name from a Germanic spring goddess named Eostre, and that the bunny and eggs were ancient fertility symbols — well. That's the moment a lot of people start asking harder questions about everything they were handed as children.
Those are good questions. They deserve real answers. And the real answers are, if anything, more interesting than the sanitized versions — because they reveal something that actually matters about how human beings have always marked time, celebrated seasons, escaped the grind, and reached toward the sacred.
Holidays — all of them, even the weird ones — are humanity's recurring attempt to interrupt the ordinary with something that feels bigger than the ordinary. Whether that's dressing up as a ghost one night a year, or lighting candles in the darkest week of winter, or gathering around a table to eat a meal you've been looking forward to all week — the impulse is the same. It always was. And it connects to something real about how God designed this particular kind of creature called human.
God did not create the world because it was on His to-do list. "Tuesday: fish. Wednesday: man. Thursday: rest, I guess." The Creator made everything out of the overflow of a nature that is joy. And we, made in that image, need joy the way we need food. Holidays are where we go to find it.
The word itself — "holiday" means "holy day"
Old English: hāligdæg. Holy day. A day set apart from the ordinary. A day when normal rules of work and productivity and getting-things-done were suspended so that a different kind of reality could come forward. The ancient world — every culture in every era — understood that human beings needed these interruptions built into the calendar. Not as reward for productivity. As essential maintenance for the soul.
The Jewish tradition took this so seriously that God built it into the Ten Commandments. Not "try to rest when you can." A commandment. One day in seven, you stop. You remember that you are not the engine of the universe. You let everything run without you for a day — which, if you have ever tried it, turns out to be the single most countercultural act available to a modern person. The Sabbath was not a suggestion. It was a weekly reset, a recurring holy day built into the very structure of time itself.
And here is the thing about the Jewish Sabbath that most people don't know: it was not solemn and heavy. It was celebrated. The rabbis taught that the Sabbath was to be welcomed like a bride — with joy, with festivity, with the best meal of the week, with rest that was genuinely restful rather than guilty. Jewish families talked about it all week. They looked forward to it all week. They prepared for it all week. The holy day was the highlight, not an obligation.
Which raises the obvious question: how many of us look forward to Sunday all week the way first-century Jews looked forward to Saturday? And if the answer is "not many of us," what does that tell us about what we've done with the idea of a holy day?
The children were onto something
Jesus said this knowing full well what children are like. They are not sitting quietly with their hands folded reviewing theology. They are running. Laughing. Completely present. Completely delighted. Completely unguarded. That is the vibration Jesus was pointing at.
When you were nine years old and Halloween arrived, you were not thinking about the Celtic feast of Samhain or the theological implications of dressing as a ghost. You were running down the street in a costume, completely alive, completely free, completely in the moment. That state — joy without agenda, delight without strategy, presence without performance — is exactly the frequency on which the divine most easily reaches us.
Maybe holidays are God's recurring permission slip to be that child again. To take a break from the identity of "responsible adult managing things" and remember that the universe is fundamentally joyful — that it was made that way, that you were made that way, and that the work and the worry are the interruption, not the other way around.
We have the order backwards. We treat work as the real thing and vacation as the reward if you earn it. But consider: if the Creator made everything out of joy, and you are made in the Creator's image, then joy is not the exception. It is the original condition. Work is not punishment — it is participation in creation, which is inherently satisfying when you are doing what you were made for. But we have built systems so disconnected from that original joy that we need an official cultural permission to feel it again. Enter: holidays.
Summer vacation. Christmas morning. The first day of a long weekend. Your birthday — the one day you get to announce without apology that today is about you, and somehow the universe seems to agree. Every one of these is a small portal back to the original state. The state where you are not performing, not producing, not justifying your existence by what you accomplish. You are just here, alive, connected, glad.
Where our holidays actually came from — the honest version
Here is the part Religion 101 gave you without enough context. Yes, many of the holidays we call Christian borrowed heavily from older traditions. The early church was remarkably practical about this. If a community was already gathering for a winter solstice festival and lighting fires to welcome back the sun — why not meet them there and tell them about the true light of the world? The form was borrowed. The content was baptized.
The Urantia papers describe this as the natural interaction of evolutionary and revelatory religion — human beings reaching upward with the tools and symbols available to them, and the divine meeting them there rather than insisting they abandon everything familiar before they could receive anything new. That is not compromise. That is grace.
🎄 Christmas — "The Unconquered Sun" becomes the Light of the World
December 25 was the Roman festival of Sol Invictus — the Unconquered Sun — celebrating the return of light after the winter solstice. Early Christians presented Jesus as the true "Sun of Righteousness" (Malachi 4:2), superseding pagan solar deities. The Christmas tree came from Germanic Yule traditions. Holly was associated with the Roman god Saturn; mistletoe was sacred to Norse and Celtic peoples. None of this diminishes the Incarnation. God coming into human flesh is the most astonishing event in the history of the universe — and it doesn't need December 25 to be true. What the date gives us is a moment to stop every year and remember it together. That is worth keeping, whatever the Romans were doing with the solstice.
🥚 Easter — a Germanic spring goddess, a Jewish Passover, and an empty tomb
Easter overlaps with springtime pagan festivals, particularly those honoring the goddess Ostara, who represented fertility and renewal. The Easter bunny and decorated eggs are remnants of these earlier celebrations — eggs symbolize new life, and the rabbit was known for its fertility. The date itself is calculated from the Jewish Passover calendar — which is not accidental, since the Last Supper was a Passover meal and the crucifixion happened during Passover week. The bunny is borrowed. The resurrection is not. The resurrection is the hinge on which all of history turns, and it would be just as real if we celebrated it with no rabbits whatsoever. But the eggs of new life and the flowers of spring are not a bad backdrop for the day death lost.
🎃 Halloween — the night before All Saints Day
Bonfires, costumes, and trick-or-treating have their roots in the original Samhain rituals — the Celtic harvest festival when the boundary between the living and the dead was believed to be thinnest. The church responded by placing All Saints Day on November 1st — the eve of which became All Hallows' Eve, then Halloween. The church's instinct was actually sound: if this is the night when people feel the nearness of death, let's talk about the saints who faced death and won. The candy and costumes are a long way from that. But the underlying human instinct — to face the scary thing once a year with laughter and community — is not foolish. It is honest.
❤️ Valentine's Day — a martyred priest, a Roman fertility festival, and Hallmark
The historical St. Valentine was a third-century Roman priest who reportedly married Christian couples in secret when it was forbidden — and was executed for it. The romantic associations came later, partly overlapping with the Roman fertility festival Lupercalia in mid-February. Chaucer's poetry in the 1300s helped cement the idea that birds chose their mates on this day. The holiday has drifted a long way from its origins — but a day dedicated to love, to saying out loud that someone matters to you, to choosing connection over isolation — that is not a bad use of February. The cards may be commercial. The love they point toward is real.
🦃 Thanksgiving — ancient harvest gratitude, colonial mythology, and Abraham Lincoln
Harvest thanksgiving festivals are universal — every agrarian culture that has ever existed has had one. The specific American Thanksgiving myth oversimplifies a complicated history between Pilgrims and the Wampanoag people. Lincoln formalized it as a national holiday in 1863 during the Civil War — partly as an act of deliberate national cohesion. Strip away the mythology and what remains is genuinely important: one day a year when the entire culture is culturally expected to stop, gather, eat together, and say out loud what they are grateful for. Gratitude is one of the fastest paths from scarcity to abundance consciousness. The turkey is incidental. The table is not.
The biblical feasts — cliff notes for the ones church glosses over
Here is where it gets genuinely interesting — and where most Sunday school curricula leave you stranded. Jesus was Jewish. He observed these feasts from childhood. When he did things during these holidays, he was speaking directly into their symbolism in ways his audience caught immediately and we usually miss entirely.
🐑 Passover (Pesach) — spring, 8 days
Commemorates Israel's deliverance from Egypt — the blood of a lamb on the doorposts, death passing over the marked houses, freedom from 400 years of slavery. This is the most important feast to understand if you want to understand Jesus. His last supper was a Passover meal. His crucifixion happened during Passover. The imagery of a lamb whose blood brings deliverance — that was not new language when Paul used it. Every person in the room knew exactly what it pointed at. Christianity did not replace Passover. It claimed to be its fulfillment.
🌾 Pentecost / Shavuot — 50 days after Passover
Originally a wheat harvest celebration. Later came to commemorate God giving the Law to Moses at Sinai. For the disciples gathered in Jerusalem, it was a Jewish harvest holiday they had observed all their lives. And then: wind, fire, languages they'd never learned, and suddenly afraid people became bold people. The same feast that celebrated the giving of the written Law became the day the living Spirit arrived. That's not coincidence. That's the pattern — God meets humanity in the moments they have already set aside to look for him.
🌿 Feast of Tabernacles (Sukkot) — fall, 7 days
Jewish families built temporary outdoor shelters and lived in them for a week — remembering the forty years Israel wandered in the wilderness, dependent entirely on God for food and water. Jesus stood up during this feast and said "if anyone is thirsty, let him come to me and drink" — which landed like a thunderclap, because the feast included elaborate water-pouring ceremonies. He was not speaking generically. He was speaking directly into the symbolism of what everyone was already celebrating. They heard it. We usually don't.
🕯 Yom Kippur — the Day of Atonement
The one day when the High Priest entered the innermost room of the Temple — the Holy of Holies — and made atonement for the entire nation. The entire nation fasted. When the New Testament describes Jesus as the eternal high priest who entered the true Holy of Holies with his own blood — that is Yom Kippur language. Without knowing Yom Kippur, the book of Hebrews is a puzzle. With it, the whole thing comes into focus and takes your breath away.
🎺 Rosh Hashanah — Jewish New Year, Feast of Trumpets
The blowing of the shofar — a ram's horn — to begin the Jewish New Year. Theologically it was a call to wake up, reflect, repent, begin again. The shofar blast was a spiritual alarm clock. Many New Testament scholars connect the imagery of trumpets sounding at the end of time to this feast. At least once a year, a loud, impossible-to-ignore sound says: pay attention. Something important is happening. Be awake for it.
🕎 Hanukkah — Festival of Lights, 8 days, winter
Not one of the original Mosaic feasts, but significant. Celebrates the rededication of the Temple after the Maccabees drove out Greek oppressors — and the miracle of one day's worth of oil lasting eight days. The Gospel of John places Jesus in Jerusalem during Hanukkah, calling it "the Feast of Dedication." There Jesus says "I am the light of the world" — during the Festival of Lights. When he said it, the Hanukkah lamps were burning all over the city.
What you get to do with all of this
Here is the liberating thing about living in the modern world: you get to choose. You can celebrate Halloween as a neighborhood joy-fest where kids run around in costumes and feel briefly free and delightful — and it doesn't have to be about Celtic harvest spirits. You can celebrate Christmas as the deliberate interruption of winter darkness with the most extravagant light show your neighborhood has ever seen — and let that point, if you want it to, toward the one who called himself the light of the world. You can celebrate Easter with a new dress and colored eggs and also with the actual weight of what resurrection means.
Paul wrote about this directly — people asking whether they could eat meat that had been sacrificed to idols. His answer was essentially: the idol is not real, so the meat is just meat. What matters is the state of your heart, not the origin of the tradition. A Christmas tree is just a tree. What you bring to it is yours to choose.
The origin of a holiday tells you where it came from. What you do with it tells you where you are going.
Every holiday is an invitation — to joy, to remembrance, to gratitude, to presence. You don't have to earn the invitation. You don't have to understand the full history. You just have to show up, be present, and let yourself feel whatever the day is trying to give you.
God did not rest on the seventh day because he was tired. He rested because rest is what completion looks like from the inside — the satisfaction of a thing done well, participated in fully, savored rather than immediately replaced by the next task. He built that rhythm into the fabric of creation. Seven days. One to stop. One to breathe. One to remember that the world ran fine before you started helping and will run fine when you stop.
Holidays are extensions of that Sabbath impulse. They are the culture's way of building in the stops, the celebrations, the collective exhales. Some of them have deeply theological roots. Some of them have deeply pagan roots. Most of them have both. None of that changes what they can do for you — if you actually show up to them with presence rather than obligation, with joy rather than stress, with the openness of a child who hasn't yet been taught to be suspicious of fun.
Holy days. Harvest festivals. One night a year to be mischievous. One morning a year to find what's hidden in the yard. All of it pointing at the same thing.
The Easter bunny has nothing to do with Jesus. And also — a child running through a yard in a new spring dress, shrieking with joy at a basket of chocolate in the morning light, is about as close to the kingdom of heaven as most adults get all year. Both things are true simultaneously.
Go find your favorite holiday. Celebrate it with everything you have. Let it be ridiculous and joyful and loud and full of people you love. Assign it whatever meaning makes it come alive for you. Light the candles. Eat the food. Give the gifts. Wear the costume. Run down the street.
When you are at play, feeling love, feeling fun, feeling free — that is when the energy that creates worlds can most easily reach you. That is when you are most yourself. That is when the whole thing makes sense. The Creator didn't make you to grind. He made you to participate. Holidays are the recurring reminder that participation includes joy. Always has. Always will.
Have fun. That was always the point.
Join the conversation
Comments & ideas
Have a thought, a question, or something this stirred up? Leave it below.
Loading comments…
Keep exploring
Related Bible questions
- Where did Cain find a wife — and what was the land of Nod?
- Who is Melchizedek?
- Why so much war in the Old Testament — and why kill the children?
- Why did God threaten to kill Moses — over a foreskin?
- The book of Job — what is it actually about?
- Why all the measurements? The Temple, the Ark, and sacred geometry
- Why did Jesus have to die on the cross?
- Where was Jesus between ages 12 and 30?